Maglite XL50 VS XL200

Last Updated on September 11, 2025

When it comes to flashlights, one name always stands out — Maglite. Since its founding in 1979 by Anthony Maglica in California, USA, Maglite has become one of the most trusted and recognized flashlight brands in the world. Known for their rugged build, reliability, and long-lasting performance, Maglite flashlights are widely used by law enforcement officers, outdoor adventurers, emergency responders, and everyday users.

Related: Maglite ML300L Review: LED 3-Cell D Flashlight

Over the years, Maglite has released many models, but two of the most popular for everyday carry (EDC) are the Maglite XL50 and the Maglite XL200. At first glance, these two flashlights may look very similar. Both are compact, use AAA batteries, and are built from tough aircraft-grade aluminum. However, when you take a closer look, there are important differences in brightness, runtime, beam distance, and features that can make one a better fit than the other depending on your needs.

In this Maglite XL50 vs XL200 review, we will compare both models in detail. We’ll go through their specifications, features, pros and cons, and real-world performance. By the end, you’ll know exactly which one is the best choice for you—whether you need a reliable tactical flashlight, a compact EDC tool, or a long-lasting emergency light for power outages.

Features Details: Maglite XL50 VS XL200

Features	Maglite XL50	Maglite XL200
Water Resistant:	Yes	Yes
Lumens:	200 lumens	170 lumens
Beam Distance:	224 Meters	163 Meters
Maximum Runtime:	25h	218h
Minimum Runtime:	6h 45min (200 lm)	1h 45min (170 lm)
USB Recharge Option:	No	No
Peak Beam Intensity:	12533	6663
Modes:	3	5
Battery Include:	Yes	Yes
Voltage:	4.5 volts	1.5 volts
Length:	121.92 mm	121.92 mm
Weight:	106 grams	106 grams
Item Dimensions:	4.8 x 0.98 x 0.98 in	7.99 x 2.99 x 2.99 in
Price:	Check Price	Check Price

Maglite XL50 Review – Compact & Reliable

The Maglite XL50 is one of the most popular flashlights in the Maglite XL series, designed especially for people who want a simple, durable, and bright everyday carry (EDC) light. It combines American engineering with tough materials, making it a favorite for outdoor enthusiasts, law enforcement officers, security guards, and homeowners.

Design & Build Quality

The Maglite XL50 is made from aircraft-grade aluminum, which makes it both strong and lightweight. At just 4.8 inches long and weighing around 106 grams, it is extremely compact and easy to carry in your pocket, backpack, or glove compartment. The slim design means it won’t feel bulky, and the anodized finish protects it from scratches, corrosion, and harsh weather conditions. Additionally, the flashlight is water-resistant (IPX4 rated) and can survive drops of up to 1 meter, which makes it durable enough for camping, hiking, or emergency use.

Brightness & Beam Performance

One of the biggest strengths of the Maglite XL50 is its light output. It delivers up to 200 lumens of brightness, which is enough to clearly illuminate your path in dark areas, search for items in low light, or provide visibility during a power outage. Its beam distance reaches 224 meters, which is impressive for such a small and lightweight flashlight. This long throw makes it suitable for outdoor activities like hiking, hunting, or even tactical use.

Check Today’s Price

Lighting Modes

The XL50 offers three lighting modes controlled by a QuickClik tailcap switch. You can cycle through them with simple presses:

• Full Power (100%) – maximum brightness at 200 lumens.
• Low Power (25%) – reduced brightness for extended runtime.
• Emergency Strobe Mode – flashing light that can be used for signaling in emergencies or alerting others to your presence.

This makes it versatile enough for everyday carry without overwhelming you with too many complicated settings.

Battery Life & Power Source

The Maglite XL50 is powered by three AAA alkaline batteries, which are included with the flashlight. In low mode (25 lumens), it can run for up to 25 hours, making it reliable for long trips or power outages. On high mode (200 lumens), the runtime is about 6 hours 45 minutes, which is quite good for a compact AAA flashlight. However, it does not support USB charging, so you’ll need to keep extra AAA batteries on hand.

Pros of the Maglite XL50

• Sturdy and durable aluminum construction for long-lasting use.
• Bright 200-lumen beam with an excellent throw of 224 meters.
• Simple 3-mode operation (high, low, strobe) – easy for beginners.
• Compact and lightweight – perfect for everyday carry.
• Resistant to water splashes and impact up to 1 meter.
• Ships with batteries included.

Cons of the Maglite XL50

• Some users report that the actual output feels closer to 139 lumens instead of the advertised 200.

• The QuickClik tail switch may wear out over time with heavy use.

• No built-in USB charging option (requires replacing AAA batteries).

Who Should Buy the Maglite XL50?

The Maglite XL50 is ideal for people who want a compact, budget-friendly, and durable flashlight for daily use. It’s great for:

• Homeowners who want a handy light during power outages.
• Outdoor hobbyists, campers, or hikers who need a portable but bright flashlight.
• Security guards and first responders who value a long beam distance and simple operation.

If you want more lighting modes, longer runtime, and advanced features, you might prefer the Maglite XL200—but if you want more brightness in a simple, rugged, and affordable package, the Maglite XL50 is a great choice.

Maglite XL200 Review – Feature-Rich Everyday Carry Light

If the Maglite XL50 is known for its simplicity and brightness, the Maglite XL200 is celebrated for its versatility and advanced features. Designed for users who want more control over their flashlight, the XL200 combines reliability with smart functions that go beyond just on/off lighting.

Check Today’s Price

Design & Build Quality

The Maglite XL200 shares the same overall compact form factor as the XL50, measuring 4.8 inches in length and weighing 106 grams. Despite being lightweight and portable, it’s built with precision-machined aluminum alloy that can withstand rough use. The body is anodized inside and out, which enhances corrosion resistance and improves durability in outdoor conditions.

It is also water-resistant (IPX4 rated), meaning it can handle rain and splashes, and it has been tested to withstand drops from up to 1 meter. This makes the XL200 a dependable option for camping, hiking, and tactical use.

Light Output & Beam Distance

The Maglite XL200 delivers a maximum of 172 lumens with a beam distance of 138 meters. While it isn’t quite as bright as the Maglite XL50 (200 lumens and 224 meters throw), it still provides ample light for everyday tasks, outdoor adventures, or emergency situations.

What sets it apart is its focus on control and adaptability. Instead of fixed brightness levels only, the XL200 allows you to adjust brightness continuously by twisting your wrist while pressing the tail switch. This gives you the flexibility to choose exactly how much light you need, which can save battery power.

Lighting Modes

The XL200 has five modes, making it more versatile than the XL50’s three modes. These include:

• Full Power (172 lumens): Provides maximum brightness for outdoor use, search operations, or low-light tasks.
• 25% Power Mode: A lower brightness mode for everyday use and longer runtime.
• Strobe Mode: A flashing light for signaling or self-defense situations.
• Nite Lite Mode: Automatically adjusts brightness depending on the surrounding light levels, a feature unique to the XL200.
• Signal Mode: Lets you send Morse code signals by tapping the tail switch.

These extra modes make the Maglite XL200 a better tactical flashlight and useful for emergencies, survival situations, or outdoor adventures.

Battery Life & Power Source

Like the XL50, the XL200 runs on 3 × AAA batteries. However, its runtime is significantly longer:

• Low Mode: Up to 218 hours (over a week of continuous runtime).
• High Mode: Around 1h 45m at full brightness.

This makes it a great choice if you need a flashlight that can last a long time on lower brightness settings.

Pros of the Maglite XL200

• 5 versatile modes for different scenarios (including SOS and Nite Lite).
• Excellent battery efficiency with up to 218 hours of runtime on low mode.
• Motion-controlled brightness adjustment with a simple wrist twist.
• Strong and durable aluminum alloy body, resistant to impact and water.
• Compact size for everyday carry.
• Batteries included.

Cons of the Maglite XL200

• Slightly less bright (172 lumens) than the XL50.
• Some users have reported battery drain issues if batteries are left inside for too long.
• Bulkier in diameter compared to the XL50, though still portable.

Who Should Buy the Maglite XL200?

The Maglite XL200 is perfect for users who want more control, longer battery life, and advanced modes in a small package. If you often go camping, hiking, or find yourself in situations where you need a reliable emergency light, this flashlight will serve you well. The SOS and Nite Lite functions make it particularly appealing for outdoor adventurers and those who want extra safety features.

In short, between Maglite XL50 vs XL200, the XL200 may not be as bright, but its extended runtime and additional features make it the better option for versatility and preparedness.

Maglite XL50 VS XL200 – Head-to-Head Comparison

When choosing between the Maglite XL50 vs XL200, it helps to put their features side by side and evaluate which one fits your lifestyle and needs better. While both flashlights are designed with Maglite’s signature durability and reliability, they serve slightly different purposes.

Brightness and Beam Distance

The Maglite XL50 produces up to 200 lumens, while the Maglite XL200 tops out at 172 lumens. This means the XL50 gives you a brighter maximum output, which is especially useful if you need to see far ahead in dark outdoor environments. Its beam reaches 224 meters, compared to the 138 meters of the XL200. If you often find yourself in open areas or need a light for long-distance visibility, the XL50 has the advantage in brightness and range.

Runtime and Battery Life

Here is where the Maglite XL200 pulls ahead. On its low mode, it can run for an astonishing 218 hours, which is nearly nine days of continuous use. The XL50, while brighter, lasts only about 25 hours on low mode. If you need a flashlight for emergency kits, disaster preparedness, or long camping trips where charging or replacing batteries isn’t always possible, the XL200 is the clear winner.

Light Modes and Functionality

• The Maglite XL50 keeps things simple with three modes: high power, low power, and strobe. This makes it an easy-to-use flashlight for people who prefer straightforward functionality.
• The Maglite XL200, however, offers five modes: high power, low power, strobe, SOS, and Nite Lite (automatic brightness adjustment). On top of that, it includes motion-controlled brightness adjustment — simply rotate your wrist while pressing the tailcap switch to control the brightness level.

If you’re looking for more control and flexibility, the Maglite XL200 is the better choice. But if you just want quick access to brightness and a strobe feature, the Maglite XL50 is sufficient.

Size and Portability

Both flashlights are 4.8 inches long and weigh around 106 grams, making them excellent EDC flashlights that fit easily in your pocket, glove box, or tool bag. The Maglite XL50 has a slimmer profile (0.98 inches diameter) compared to the XL200’s 2.99 inches, which means it’s easier to carry discreetly and more comfortable for pocket carry.

Build Quality & Durability

Both the Maglite XL50 and XL200 are built with aircraft-grade aluminum and are anodized inside and out, which improves resistance to corrosion and wear. They are both water-resistant (IPX4) and can handle drops of up to 1 meter, making them reliable for outdoor and rugged use.

Price Comparison (2025 Update)

As of 2025:

• Maglite XL50 costs around $34–$39.
• Maglite XL200 is priced a little higher at around $40–$45.

For just a few dollars more, the XL200 offers two extra modes, better runtime, and advanced brightness control.

Buying Guide – Choosing Between Maglite XL50 VS XL200

When shopping for a reliable flashlight, it’s important to think about your specific needs. Both the Maglite XL50 and Maglite XL200 are durable, compact, and made in the USA from high-strength aluminum. However, they serve slightly different purposes. Below is a detailed buying guide to help you decide which one suits you best.

1. Purpose of Use

• Maglite XL50 is perfect if you need a bright everyday carry flashlight for household use, walking the dog, short hikes, or keeping in your car for emergencies. Its 200-lumen beam and long 224-meter throw make it ideal for spotting objects at a distance.
• Maglite XL200 is a better choice if you want a multi-functional tool. With its five lighting modes, including SOS and Nite Lite, it works well for camping, night walks, and emergency preparedness kits.

2. Brightness & Beam Range

• XL50: Brighter at 200 lumens with an impressive 224-meter beam distance, giving you powerful illumination for outdoor activities.
• XL200: Slightly dimmer at 172 lumens and a shorter 138-meter beam distance, but still effective for most EDC and tactical uses.

If you often need to see far into the distance, the Maglite XL50 is the winner. But if you want versatility, the XL200 offers more options even with a lower max brightness.

3. Battery Life

Battery life can be the deciding factor, especially for camping or emergency use.

• XL50: Runs up to 25 hours on low mode (25 lumens) and about 6h 45m on high.
• XL200: Runs an incredible 218 hours on low mode and around 1h 45m on high.

If you value extended runtime, the Maglite XL200 clearly outperforms the XL50. However, if you often use your light at full brightness, the XL50 provides stronger illumination for a longer period on its highest setting.

4. Ease of Use

Both models feature a push-button tailcap switch, making them convenient to operate with one hand.

• XL50: Uses the QuickClik system, allowing you to quickly cycle between high, low, and strobe modes.
• XL200: Adds a motion-sensitive brightness control and includes more modes, which can be useful but may feel slightly more complex for users who prefer simplicity.

5. Portability & Design

• Maglite XL50: Slimmer (0.98 inches diameter) and very lightweight (106 g). It fits easily in a pocket or small bag, making it a great EDC flashlight.
• Maglite XL200: Same length (4.8 inches), but thicker (2.99 inches diameter), so it feels bulkier in the pocket. On the other hand, it offers more grip and a slightly more tactical design.

6. Budget & Value

• XL50: ~$34–$39 – more affordable, great if you just want a simple, bright, and reliable flashlight without extra features.
• XL200: ~$40–$45 – a bit pricier, but the longer runtime and extra lighting modes provide excellent value for outdoor, tactical, or emergency use.

Final Recommendation

When comparing Maglite XL50 vs XL200, both are excellent choices depending on what you need:

• Pick the Maglite XL50 if you want maximum brightness (200 lumens), a longer beam distance, and a simple 3-mode design at a budget-friendly price.
• Pick the Maglite XL200 if you prefer long-lasting runtime (up to 218 hours), advanced lighting modes like SOS and Nite Lite, and greater control over brightness.

For homeowners, casual users, and those who want a slim EDC flashlight, the Maglite XL50 is more than enough. For campers, hikers, emergency responders, or anyone who values battery efficiency and versatility, the Maglite XL200 is the smarter investment.

Still, have any questions in this Maglite XL50 VS XL200 Review? Comment below